卡片召唤师
精华
|
战斗力 鹅
|
回帖 0
注册时间 2020-8-13
|
我找了下polygon的评测(注,polygon现在只写评测,但不打分)
https://www.polygon.com/reviews/ ... endo-switch-spinoff
贝3出来的出来的时候,polygon评测的标题是《贝姐3让我心碎了》,当时我就很惊讶这么强的粉丝化视角能出现在评测里,于是我很好奇这次他们说了什么
可惜的是,起源和贝3不是同一个编辑写的,所以无法直接对比
果不其然,这篇评测印证了我上面的评价,也就是前2代贝姐的小众cult味太冲了,以至于白金在衍生作(甚至包括3代)想转型难免招致这部分玩家的不自觉抵触。如果说上面的底分媒体和VGC没那么明显的话以至于被人误会为典中典胡乱打分的话,那么polygon的这篇评测就非常的明显,而且可能是因为没有打分压力的关系,说话毫无顾忌。打分媒体多少还想找好话说(实在找不到好话那就只能说点废话),但这篇评测就很少找好话,如果找好话说单纯也是用来标榜自己的——让自己显得没那么主观
关于起源,polygon的标题是,Bayonetta’s new spinoff can’t decide what it wants to be
实际上这跟底分媒体和VGC的疑问是一样的,也就是不知道这游戏想干啥
在简单介绍了开头的剧情后,接下来就是狂喷了
喷人设没贝姐味,喷战斗没贝姐味,喷剧情和游戏机制都不是自己所期待的
“As for those characters: Can we really have a Bayonetta game without tight (and disappearing) costumes, overtly sexual dancing, and heel guns? I think it might be possible. But Cereza and the Lost Demon definitely doesn’t succeed in bridging that gap. Platinum gives us a look into the witch’s early life and the unique relationship with the demons she wields, but it lacks the “fuck you” attitude and guns-blazing combat that made the earlier games so propulsive. The title feels more like a family-friendly fanfic attempting to tie the wild finale of Bayonetta 3 back to the witch’s childhood. Is it sweet, frothy, and the easiest (in a mechanical sense) jumping-off point for people new to the franchise? Absolutely. But does it push the envelope, like the previous games did, for better or worse? I’m not so sure. ”
比如这段话,看似并没有否定这作的新路线。但仔细阅读的话,明显这里的possible也好,I’m not so sure也好,都是为了行文而进行的表面让步和委婉语
polygon的评测没直接说游戏的剧情怎么样,但从这句话来说,她明显认为可以做的很好
“There were so many other stories, relationships, and mechanics that could have been explored to make this title not only as detailed as the originals, but also more rewarding for series veterans and newcomers alike. ”
楼主质问编辑怎么忍心给这么可爱的小家伙这么低的分数,某种意义上这就是原因,这个游戏系列营造了某个非常根深蒂固的粉丝的既成视角,以至于部分玩家会用很牢固的成见来看待系列作。(很难想象这个女编辑口味这么重,按道理女性应该对小清新风格更为欣赏才是)
“For those, like me, hoping to see how Cereza truly gained her power, and harnessed the seduction and raw magical prowess required to become the ultimate umbra witch, this game is a miss. ”
当然,我知道诸位会说这种评测没有价值,通篇个人化的意见领袖式呓语。但反过来,现在的情况并不是当初神海4的情况。神海4在MC均分94的时候,来了个哗众取宠的**打了40分,那朝底媒一顿输出是可以理解的。但是这作均分才80,与其说输出底媒,不如说是什么原因和底层脑回路导致媒体打了低分更值得关注 |
评分
-
查看全部评分
|